Quick answer:
Asana is best for teams seeking a simple, user-friendly task manager focused on internal client projects with minimal billing needs. Teamwork, on the other hand, excels at managing complex, client-billable projects with native invoicing, time tracking, and client portals, making it ideal for agencies requiring transparent client collaboration and financial oversight.

Key Decision Factors to Choose Between Asana and Teamwork

  • Project complexity: Use Asana for simple to moderately complex projects; choose Teamwork for multi-phase, dependency-heavy workflows.
  • Client interaction: If clients need occasional or no access, Asana suffices; frequent client visibility and collaboration favor Teamwork.
  • Billing and time tracking: If billing and time logging are critical, Teamwork’s built-in tools outperform Asana’s reliance on integrations.
  • User interface preference: Prefer a minimalist, intuitive UI? Asana fits well; need feature-rich dashboards? Teamwork leads.
  • Collaboration style: Task-focused with lightweight chats points to Asana; integrated messaging plus client portals lean toward Teamwork.
  • Budget considerations: Asana offers more accessible entry-level plans; Teamwork caters to mid-to-large teams with advanced needs at higher tiers.

Decision Rubric

| Criteria | Asana | Teamwork | Recommended When |
|-------------------------|--------------------------------|-------------------------------------------|------------------------------------|
| Onboarding & Ease | Quick, simple UI | More features, steeper learning curve | Need fast start |
| Client Billing & Time | Via integrations | Native comprehensive tracking and billing | Billing is core function |
| Client Access | Limited guest permissions | Dedicated client portals | Clients need direct project access |
| Task & Workflow Style | Flexible boards, lists, timeline | Advanced workflows, milestones, dependencies | Complex project management |
| Reporting & Analytics | Basic dashboards, customizable | Detailed financial and project reporting | Require deep insights |

Detailed Comparison and Insights

Why Choose Asana for Client Projects?

Asana offers a clean, intuitive interface that simplifies task assignment, progress tracking, and deadline management. It supports multiple project views like lists, boards, and timelines enabling teams to maintain clear visibility on deliverables. For projects where clients are passive or suffciently managed via updates rather than access, Asana’s low-overhead design minimizes complexity. While it lacks native time tracking or invoicing, its vast integration ecosystem (e.g., time trackers, billing apps) can fill these gaps for smaller-scale or non-billable projects.

Why Teamwork Works Best for Client-Billable Projects

Teamwork is tailored for agencies managing client billing, time tracking, and complex project structures within one platform. It offers dedicated client portals allowing external stakeholders to monitor progress, approve tasks, and access shared files, which streamlines communication and reduces email overload. Robust features including milestones, task dependencies, expense tracking, and invoicing support make Teamwork excellent for projects requiring financial transparency and accountability. This power comes with a steeper learning curve and longer setup time but provides a richer toolbox for multi-client agencies.

Additional Considerations

  • If your workflow relies heavily on in-platform financial tools, Teamwork’s integrated billing eliminates the need for external invoicing software.
  • Teams preferring agile or kanban styles with minimal client-facing needs benefit from Asana’s flexible boards and automation options.
  • Both platforms support CSV data export/import and integrate well with common business tools like Slack, Outlook, and Google Workspace, easing migration challenges.

Use-case Scenarios

Freelance Consultant Managing Client Deliverables

A solo consultant uses Asana to manage multiple client tasks and deadlines without integrated billing. The platform keeps task management lightweight and avoids unnecessary complexity, while billing is handled externally via accounting software or manual invoicing.

Digital Agency Running Multi-client Campaigns with Billing

A mid-size digital agency employs Teamwork to coordinate campaigns, track billable hours, and manage client invoicing—all within one platform. Clients access project statuses and approve deliverables via client portals, significantly reducing email volume and improving transparency.

Side-by-side Feature Comparison

| Feature | Asana | Teamwork |
|--------------------------|-----------------------------------------|--------------------------------------|
| Task Management | Flexible boards, lists, timeline views | Milestones, task dependencies, detailed workflows |
| Client Access | Limited guest permissions | Dedicated client portals |
| Time Tracking | Requires third-party integrations | Native tracking with billing integration |
| Budget & Invoicing | No native support | Full invoicing and expense management |
| Reporting & Analytics | Basic reports and customizable dashboards| Advanced project financial insights |
| Collaboration Tools | Comments, mentions, lightweight chat | Built-in messaging and notifications |
| Ease of Use | Intuitive and minimalistic | Feature-rich with steeper learning curve |

Strengths and Weaknesses

Asana Strengths

  • Very easy onboarding and use
  • Multiple visualization options for tasks
  • Strong automation rules and integration support
  • Well-suited to teams without billing requirements

Asana Limitations

  • No native invoicing or time tracking
  • Limited client-facing collaborative features
  • Less optimal for managing complex dependencies

Teamwork Strengths

  • Designed with client billing and time tracking in mind
  • Fully featured client portals enhance transparency
  • Supports complex workflows with milestones and dependencies
  • Robust reporting on finances and project progress

Teamwork Limitations

  • Steeper learning curve due to feature density
  • Higher pricing tiers for full-feature access
  • UI is denser and less agile compared to minimalist platforms

How to Decide: Client Project Management Checklist

  • Do you require integrated billing and time tracking inside the platform?
  • Will clients need regular access to project updates or interactive portals?
  • How complex are your projects (dependencies, phases, milestones)?
  • How quickly must your team onboard new software?
  • What level of reporting and financial visibility is necessary?
  • What budget constraints do you have for project management tools?

Answer these honestly; simpler, internal-focused teams lean toward Asana, while client-facing, billable project teams benefit more from Teamwork.

FAQ

Can Asana handle client billing and invoicing directly?

No, Asana does not have built-in billing or invoicing capabilities; users need to rely on third-party integrations or external tools for those functions.

Is Teamwork suitable for agencies with multiple clients?

Yes, Teamwork is built to manage numerous client projects simultaneously, with separate billing, project spaces, and client access portals.

Does Teamwork have a steeper learning curve than Asana?

Typically yes; Teamwork’s richer feature set introduces more complexity compared to Asana’s simpler, more intuitive interface.

Can Asana and Teamwork integrate with popular accounting software?

Both platforms support integrations with common accounting and time-tracking tools, though Teamwork provides more built-in financial features requiring fewer external apps.

Which tool is better for remote teams collaborating with clients?

Teamwork’s client portals and communication features make it superior for remote client collaboration; Asana excels for internal team collaboration without extensive client involvement.

How difficult is it to migrate from one platform to another?

Both support CSV import/export and can integrate with common productivity tools, so migration is manageable but requires planning for data structuring and testing.

Next Steps

  • Assess your client project workflows against the checklist above.
  • Test both Asana and Teamwork focusing on critical features like billing, client access, and workflow complexity.
  • Consider your team’s capacity to handle onboarding complexity and long-term scalability.
  • Choose Asana for lightweight and straightforward client project management without billing needs.
  • Opt for Teamwork if client billing, invoicing, and transparent client portals are essential.
  • Prepare migration plans by exporting project data and trialing imports before committing to a platform switch.

This focused comparison equips you to decide between Asana and Teamwork based on your client project management priorities.

Where to try these tools

  • Teamwork – [Start a free trial]({{ AFFILIATE_LINK_TEAMWORK }})

Related guides